This analysis examines the strategic rivalry among the United States, China, and Russia, arguing that the future of the global order depends on whether statesmanship can overcome great-power ambition and geopolitical mistrust.
In our lead image: President Xi, President Trump, and President Putin as matryoshka dolls. Source: Facebook.
Támogatóink hozzájárulása nélkül ez a cikkünk sem készülhetett volna el. Ne csak olvassa, támogassa is lapunkat: kattintson ide.
Miklos K. Radvanyi, vice president of the Frontiers of Freedom Institute provided an analysis for Gulyáságyú Média. / Radványi Miklós, az egyesült államokbeli republikánus think-tank, a Frontiers of Freedom Institute alelnöke angol nyelvű elemzése a Gulyáságyú Média számára.
You can find all of Miklos K. Radvanyi’s opinion pieces on this link. Radványi Miklós összes írását ezen a linken találja.
The triangular relationship between the United States of America, the People’s Republic of China, and the former Soviet Union as well as the current Russian Federation has become the defining geopolitical structure of the late 20th and the first quarter of the 21st centuries. This geopolitical situation has often been described as a competition between democracy and authoritarianism, between the old superpowers and the rising challenger, or between the Western-led order and a new multipolar world. However, such definitions are too simplistic. The more discomforting reality is that all three power centers have contributed to the instability of the present age. Each sees itself as a defender of justice, historical necessity, or national destiny, each accuses the other two of hubristic arrogance and irresponsible aggression, and each has mostly ignored the limits of its own power. In reality, the real tragedy of this triangle is that the world’s three most influential military powers possess enormous capabilities, but often lack the wisdom, creativity, and statesmanship required to manage them.
America and the Limits of Unipolar Power
The United States of America entered the so-called post-Cold War era with a unique historical opportunity. Following the total collapse of the Soviet Union, the White House stood unmatched militarily, economically, and culturally. Yet, instead of a creative global strategy and balanced tactics, successive American presidents confused leadership with hubristic dominance. The “unipolar moment” encouraged the parochial belief that American values, institutions, and superficial strategic preferences represented the inevitable destiny of history. Undoubtedly, this confidence produced genuine accomplishments: expanded trade, technological innovation, security guarantees for allies, and support for democratic aspirations. Yet, it also gave impetus to strategic arrogance. The wars in Afghanistan and Iraq demonstrated the limits of the exclusive utilization of military power when it was not combined with cultural understanding and political realism. The revitalization of President Woodrow Wilson’s rallying cry on April 2, 1917, about “making the world safe for democracy” remained a catch-word to arouse enthusiasm by the American people and beyond for doing their level best for universal peace through war. The result was repeated underestimation of the complexity of the world and the difficulties of reshaping societies, as well as the overestimation of the global appeal of its own model.
Successive American presidents also failed to attempt integrating the new Russian Federation and the awakening People’s Republic of China into a durable security framework after the Cold War. Obviously, this statement does not excuse President Vladimir Putin’s repeated illegal aggressions and President Xi Jinping’s expansionist megalomania, but it raises a serious historical question: could a more creative Western strategy have avoided the rise of a permanently resentful Moscow and Beijing? Significant states defeated in ideological struggles rarely fade away. On the contrary, they nurture memories, grievances, and ambitions for the future. Finally, the United States of America has developed fundamental domestic problems. Burgeoning political polarization, short election cycles, financial imbalance, and multiplying cultural conflicts, have contributed to a more divided America that, in turn, raises doubts across the globe about the future durability of the Republic.
Russia’s Search for Great-Power Status
Sadly, the Russian Federation under President Putin, however, represents an unmitigated historical failure. As I wrote in my article “The Death of Putin’s Russia,” this former KGB Lieutenant Colonel has abysmally failed to transform his tyrannical power into progressive prosperity. Instead of building a modern and diversified state, he has hopelessly trapped the country in the old imperial Russian Orthodox mentality. Falling backward instead of striving to reform the country, under his leadership, Russia has chosen confrontation throughout the world. Having increasingly relied on pressure, energy politics, information warfare, and military force, the protracted and illegal invasion of the State of Ukraine was the ultimate expression of this universal failure. Clearly, this illegal invasion that began in 2014, showed unambiguously a 19th century understanding of power politics in the 21st century. Territorial gain has been treated as more important than domestic progression, and the broadening of spheres of influence have been valued more than human potential. As a result, Putin’s Russia has sought recognition as a great power, but at the same time destroyed its foundations necessary to maintain great-power status. In conclusion, the greatest irony is that the Kremlin’s attempt to resist Western dominance has increased its dependence on Beijing. President Putin wants to be a sovereign actor in a multipolar world. Instead, it risks becoming the weakest link in a relationship where Beijing possesses the military, technological, economic, and financial advantages.
China’s Rise and Structural Vulnerabilities
The People’s Republic of China, the third player in the triangle, presents the most disturbingly complex case. The rise of the People’s Republic of China after the founder tyrant Mao Zedong’s death in 1976, has been grossly overmystified by the official Chinese propaganda as well as its powerful misinformation apparatus, coupled with the China-obsessed crowd of fellow travelers across the globe. In reality, the country’s rise has been based on deceptive illusions that have harbored from the beginning all the reasons for its inevitable future collapse. Presenting the rising China as the sole country supposedly standing above the petty frays of politics and accordingly morally clean country, with the wisest civilization for the last 5000 years, Beijing has fooled both the majority of the so-called “China experts,” and the billions of political amateurs.
In reality, the People’s Republic of China’s reluctant modernization did not challenge the rigid tyranny one iota. Economically, its export-based system without sufficient natural resources has become lethally vulnerable to the whims of the foreign suppliers and the frequently swinging demands of the international consumer markets. Thus, without touching upon the tyrannical nature of the political system, the newly evolving doctrine has regressed to the antediluvian mandate of exchanging individual freedom for a more affordable material existence. Yet, historical examples, in particular the collapse of the so-called “Socialist Dictatorships” in Europe and beyond, taught the world that when the promise of ever rising existential wellbeing fails the survivability of the tyrannical system unavoidably always collapses. With its dangerously shrinking population as well as its aging workforce, its dwindling real estate markets, the overcapacity of its industrial establishment, it becomes vulnerable to foreign suppliers, the unregulated wings of the international consumer markets, and the growing universal disillusionment with the quality of its products, President Xi’s China is surely on its way to a Soviet-style death of the People’s Republic’s tyranny.
The Global Risks of Strategic Rivalry
The collective danger of the present triangle is that all three capitals believe history is on their side. The White House believes the appeal of individualism and innovation will ultimately prevail. The Kremlin believes that power and endurance will overcome Western weaknesses. Beijing believes that patience, discipline, and economic scale will restore its dominant place in world affairs. All three may be partially right. All three may also be deceptively wrong. The greatest threat facing the world is not that one of these powers will win. In humanity’s history, power without restraint, ambition without humility, and nationalism without responsibility have repeatedly produced catastrophes.
Meanwhile, history is waiting whether statesmanship will replace hubristic uncertainty, or creative political thinking will prevail over irresponsible adventurism.
You can comment on this article on Facebook:

